The Lady Jaspers took a one goal edge early in the contest when McMahon accepted a pass from Caroline Morse, and blasted a shot from 15 yards out past Wagner goalkeeper Leslie Reed.
Reed collected 15 saves in the contest, while Lady Jaspers' goalkeeper Caitlin Trupiano recorded five.
Wagner (2-4-2) managed to rally back late in the second stanza when Sheehan got her squad on the scoreboard after connecting on a shot from 10 yards out. The play developed when the Seahawks' defensive pressure caused a turnover in front of the cage, setting up the goal.
Overtime proved to be a defensive stalemate as both squads failed to tally the game winner. The Lady Jaspers could not connect on five shot opportunities in the second session of sudden victory, allowing the match to end in a draw.
With the tie,